credit

References

Thomas, Consumer Credit Models

Credit Scores

Developed in the 1950s, along with the first credit cards

Purpose: to judge default risk (the risk that the borrower won't pay it back)

Based on Fisher's statistical methods of classification in the 1930s

Scoring classically focused on a very specific risk: typically that the client will go 90 days overdue on their payments in the next 12 months

Credit bureaus started up; they pooled a bunch of legally available credit data on consumers

1980s

Behavioural scoring: info on the payment and purchase behaviour of clients in the recent past is used (the observation period, typically the last 12 months) along with info from credit bureaus and the classical application data

Attrition

The likelyhood that a client will move their business elsewhere

Nowadays credit is essentially saturated; people don't want much more credit, but they might be interested in moving lenders to get a better rate

Profit Scoring Systems

The new way of doing credit scores: focused on how to make the lender the most money

Profit is normally compared with volume of customers

Retail Portfolio

The portfolio of loans

We can think of the consumer as a company. The bank increasing the portfolio of a client is basically then increasing their market share

Logistic Regression

This is usually the basic way of computing a credit score. Logistic regression allows you to estimate how likely it is that a certain event will occur.

For some reason, instead of looking at values between 0 and 1, credit scores normalize it to be between something like 0 and 1000, but the same idea applies.

With this in mind, we can try to optimize our credit score

Impacting Credit Scores

In Canada there are 2 companies — Equifax and TransUnion — that compute your credit scores. They both use the same info, but use different formulas. They give you more or less the same result, though.

The data which the model is trained on comes from 2 main sources:

  1. Prior borrowers
  2. The current credit applicant

Those then give you different categories of effective ways of improving your score.

When looking at prior borrowers, the information of whether they defaulted on the loan or not (or if the missed payments, etc.) is available.

  1. Application Scoring

    The data set is only made up of those who were actually accepted for a loan

  2. Behavioural Scoring

    We first select some cut-off date in the past, and then look at all borrowers who have data both before the cut-off and after the cut-off

Utilities

These can essentially be viewed as a form of unsecured credit, since the utility company provides the service prior to payment

Personal Line of Credit

Low interest and higher credit limits than credit cards.

Secured PLoC

Higher credit limits than unsecured. Lower interest.

There is some kind of collateral that you put up. Different institutions will take different things as collateral.

Home Equity Line of Credit:

Use your home's equity as collateral.

Unsecured PLoC

In this case, you don't put up any collateral. As a consequence, the interest is higher

Credit Card

Has much higher interest and typically a lower credit limit

The benefit of a credit card is that you can get different benefits and rewards from making purchases with them. LoC are just the credit.

Credit cards are also more widely used and accepted, so it's likely that you'll be able to buy whatever you want using them.

Personal Loan

Credit Score

Bank of Canada

Overnight / Policy Interest Rate

Every day, banks are legally required to have a certain amount of money in their reserve, to avoid bank runs

Some banks will have more than they need and some less, so they'll loan each other money.

The Bank of Canada can't directly control the rate that other banks lend at. So instead, it has a rate that it would really like them to lend at, called the policy interest rate.

The policy rate will be calculated in some fancy way, in terms of some other rates that the Bank of Canada does directly control.

By setting the rate that the BoC gives other banks for loans and savings, they incentivize banks to loan to each other at a competitive rate.

Bank Rate

The rate that the Bank of Canada will loan to other banks at

Deposit Rate

The rate that the Bank of Canada will give to people that loan it money. Basically a savings account for the other banks

Floor vs Corridor System

The range between the bank and deposit rate is called the operating band

Because the policy rate isn't set directly, and is just a target, you need some model to calculate what the policy rate will be in practice, given any set of actions by the Bank.

Corridor

This is the basic model, in which the policy rate is assumed to be halfway between the bank and deposit rates

Floor

In this model, the policy rate is very slightly above the deposit rate.

Loans

Mortgage

Mortgage loans are secured by property (like a house)

Down payment: The cash that you put upfront

Amortization

The total time it'll take to pay off your mortgage

Terms

The time a fixed mortgage contract stays in place before you'll have to renew your mortgage

In the US, these periods can be 30 years long, but in Canada they're much shorter

Longer terms usually have higher rates

Closed-Term

Inflexible mortgages. If you repay your mortgage outside of the rules, you'll have to pay penalties

Open-Term

Have higher rates, but you can pay off early

Ratio

Low ratio: Down payment is at least 20%

High ratio: Less than 20%

One interesting thing you can do is to get the 20%, but then do less than it anyway, and invest the difference; the returns on the investment can offset the extra premiums

Rate

Fixed Rate

You rate is locked in for the whole term

Good if you lock in low Bad if you lock in high

Variable Rate

If the prime rate changes, your payment stays the same, but you pay more/less to the principle compared to the interest

Better if the interest rate goes up — more gets paid to the principle. Not good if the rate goes down — you just pay relatively more interest

Adjustable Rate

Your rate over the course of the term changes with the lender's prime rate

Better if interest rate goes down — you pay less. Worse if interest rate goes up — you pay more

Conventional Mortgage

So-called "house hacking":

Buy a duplex, rent out one side, which pays off your mortgage

Tax

Mortgages have a number of tax benefits

Reverse Mortgage

Debt Consolidation

If you have different credit types with different levels of interest, you can pay off some of the debt with other debt: this is consolidation