Mayer, Invest Like a Dealmaker
John Burr Williams, The Theory of Investment Value (1930)
Williams noted that the price of a stock is determined by the marginal opinion, rather than the majority.
Mayer views the market as having two halves:
Money can be made when these two markets exhibit different prices for the same commodity
Mayer says that professional private investors don't spend time looking at stock charts unless they're traders. We basically divide investing into two types: short-term and longterm, and the type you're doing determines the strategy and points of interest you take up
Mayer: Don't care too much about the charts Don't look at too many macro-variables
it can cloud the picture; you need to get a lot of things right to make it work
Mayer advocates for bottom-up investing, focusing on underlying value
Spend a lot of time waiting: buy a deal and wait for profit
Don't focus much on earnings
The market equity of a company is
Shares × Share Price
The value of the whole business is
Equity + Debt
this is what you'd have to pay to purchase the entire company But companies also might have a certain amount of cash saved up. So the Enterprise Value is
EV = Equity + Debt − Cash
Working capital is
WC = AR + I − AP
AR = accounts receivable AP = accounts payable I = inventory
You typically look at the derivative of working capital with respect to time
dWC/dt > 0 — money is being tied up
Typically dWC/dt > 0 when a company is growing; making more sales, doing more deals, increasing inventory, etc.
Investments the company makes in itself. Also called addition to fixed investments
CE = M + G
M = maintenance costs G = funding for growth
You have to think about whether these are reasonable expenditures in the case of each particular company
Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization
EBITDA = Inc + T + I + DA
Inc = net income T = taxes I = interest on expenses DA = depreciation and amortization
You can compare this to EV:
EV/EBITDA = (E + D - C)/(Inc + T + I + DA)
E = equity D = debt C = cash
You want this close to 0: EV depends on the market price, unlike EBITDA, which explicitly depends on the income
Physical things like buildings, land, real estate, oil, resources, etc.
Public sentiment, development costs, licenses, brand names
You want to buy assets at such a price that if the price falls, you're still ok
Assets that have multiple uses are often safer
Tangible assets are usually more precisely valued and therefore safer
Assets that rely on a lot of intangibles, like brand names, are usually over-priced
You can subtract intangibles from this to get the tangible book value From there, you want to adjust different things, depending on how you personally evaluate their worth (add value to certain things not on the balance sheet, subtract things you think aren't worth as much as they appear, etc.)