Canadian Courts

References

Russel, Canada's Trial Courts - Two Tiers or One?

Summary

Currently, civil and criminal courts have two tiers:

  1. Superior courts - staffed by federally appointed judges
  2. Provincial courts - provincially appointed judges

History

1794: Governor Simcoe creates the inferior courts in Canada.

1846: County Courts created in England.

1875: Supreme Court of Canada is established through Section 101

1971: Federal Court of Canada established through Section 101

Canada's judicial system was basically copied and pasted from the one British colonists were under.

British North America Act: The Canadian Constitution

Compare to the USA

In the states, each state has its own system of courts, and the judges are set by the states. There is also a system of federal courts for federal and inter-state issues

Canada never worried about inter-province issues, since all of the judges were appointed federally, so there was no worry about conflict of interest.

Provinces

Prairies and New Brunswick: SC is the Court of Queen's/King's Bench

Atlantic: SC is the Trial Division of the Supreme Court

British Columbia: SC is the Supreme Court of British Columbia

Northwest Territories and Yukon: SC is the Supreme Court

Nunavut: Only one court - the Nunavut Court of Justice

Quebec: had no District or County courts, but had a decentralized Superior court.

England: Superior Courts got their authority from the Crown, not Parliament; as such, there was no legislation telling them what cases they could or couldn't try.