Russel, Canada's Trial Courts - Two Tiers or One?
Currently, civil and criminal courts have two tiers:
1794: Governor Simcoe creates the inferior courts in Canada.
1846: County Courts created in England.
1875: Supreme Court of Canada is established through Section 101
1971: Federal Court of Canada established through Section 101
Canada's judicial system was basically copied and pasted from the one British colonists were under.
Section 92 (14): Provincial legislature has exclusive jurisdiction over the administration of justice in the province, including the constitution, maintenance, and organization of provincial civil and criminal courts
Section 96: The Governor General appoints the judges of the Superior, District, and County Courts in each province.
Note that in the constitution only mentions 3 different kinds of courts by name
Section 99: Judges of the SC shall hold office during good behaviour, but shall be removable by the Governor General on Address of the Senate and House of Commons.
Section 101: federal parliament can establish a General Court of Appeal for Canada, and any additional courts for the better administration of the laws of Canada
In the states, each state has its own system of courts, and the judges are set by the states. There is also a system of federal courts for federal and inter-state issues
Canada never worried about inter-province issues, since all of the judges were appointed federally, so there was no worry about conflict of interest.
Prairies and New Brunswick: SC is the Court of Queen's/King's Bench
Atlantic: SC is the Trial Division of the Supreme Court
British Columbia: SC is the Supreme Court of British Columbia
Northwest Territories and Yukon: SC is the Supreme Court
Nunavut: Only one court - the Nunavut Court of Justice
Quebec: had no District or County courts, but had a decentralized Superior court.
England: Superior Courts got their authority from the Crown, not Parliament; as such, there was no legislation telling them what cases they could or couldn't try.