1950s - 1960s
Confessional poetry was a response to Modernism and its detached, academic style. In response, confessional focused on the personal taboo: mental illness, trauma, domestic life.
Today (c. 2026) the confessional style is still prominent, but it doesn't have the same tooth, as it often discusses topics that are tame or mainstream (mental illness like anxiety and depression, as opposed to more demonized ones like NPD/BPD)
Nuclear family: The idealized family
structure was replaced in Confessional by the broken realities of
divorce, alcoholism, depression, and violence
Modernism: Confessionals hated Eliot,
who wanted poetry to escape from personality (Tradition and
the Individual Talent, 1919); for the Confessionals, poetry was
personality
Objective correlative: Eliot's idea:
you can't just say you're sad; you have to use objects and situations to
evoke the emotion
Fictional authors: William Butler Yeats [🔒 Note currently
private] and Ezra Pound used a lot of mythology and fictional
personas to speak for them. Similarly, in the Victorian era, authors
like Robert Browning used the dramatic monologue of fictional characters
to express taboo topics. Confessionals took a slightly different
approach: while John Berryman denied that Henry's narration was
actually him, Robert Lowell and Snodgrass wrote very
explicitly about themselves.
Lowell actually criticized Berryman for this. Later critics pointed out that Berryman doesn't only do this, he also writes in a minstrel dialect, having Henry speak as a character called "Mr. Bones"
New Criticism: Poems were treated as
self-contained objects. You shouldn't look to understanding the author
in in order to understand the poem, because everything you need is
already in the poem itself. Confessionals forced the reader to interact
with both the author and the poem at the same time, especially to
understand its meaning
What you know: Mark Twain said to
write what you know — meaning, Americans should stop trying to
write like Europeans; they should express the unique character
of American life. Confessional poets didn't follow this exactly; but
they did sort of an extreme analogy, wherein they wrote literally about
themselves
Death of the Author:
Slop: Sexton and Berryman both
criticized poets who mistook suffering for art; Confessional was
powerful not just because it was autobiographical, but because it
confession was crafted into a work of art
Autobiographical: Confessional allowed
and encouraged the poet to write about their own experiences, in the
first-person
Taboo: Suicide, mental illness,
addiction, sex
Confession is poetry that removes the mask of the author
Vulnerability:
Written about The Dream Songs. He tells the reader that the narrator of the poems is not the author John Berryman
The inspiration for Robert Lowell. He wrote about the pain of his divorce
Published letters from his wife without her permission
Wrote about his manic depression and ancestral trauma
In reviewing it, M.L. Rosenthal coined the term Confessional Poetry
Unlike Lowell, who was well-off, Sexton was middle-class. She wrote of the suburban life of a housewife, in all honesty: abortion, menstruation, masturbation, postpartum depression, the fear of killing her children
Therapy: Sexton started writing because
her therapist thought it would be a good way to process her trauma
Subconscious: She approached poetry as
a way of engaging with her subconscious
Performance: She liked to perform her
poems, sometimes with a band called Anne Sexton and Her
Kind
Criticism: Critics felt like she was
turning away from art and just doing emotional
exhibitionism
Motherhood, menstruation, mental breakdowns
Berryman writes of a fractured self, named Henry, who also exists as a blackface character called Mr Bones by Henry's unnamed friend.
Pronouns: Berryman speaks not only as
the authorial-I, but as other pronouns: he, we, you
Form: All of the Dream Songs are three
stanzas of six lines each (so 666)
Voice: The poetry constantly jumps
between high and low voice, slang, archaic words, slant rhyme and
full