Individual: The Harlem Renaissance
focused on the expression of the individual Black
American.
Paul Laurence Dunbar: Wrote in a
combination of "high" European, formal voice and "low" AAE
Francis Ellen Watkins Harper:
Phillis Wheatley:
W.E.B. Dubois: His essay The
Talented Tenth, which appeared in the collection The Negro
Problem, argued that a particular class of Black people in the US
would / should lead and improve the Black community; the Tenth were
those Black American men that got a college (classical) education.
Langston Hughes was very against this concept. He hated the idea that
Black people had to capitulate to white structures
Propaganda: Dubois believed that all
Black art must be propaganda, designed to demonstrate
to the whites that Black people were just as talented as them.
Propaganda: Thought that Dubois was
wrong for sending Black artists on a propagandic quest. The primary
responsibility of any artist is to communicate something
universal
Ethnic race: Locke argued that race was
primarily social and cultural not biological.
Politics: He considered it sometimes
useful to think and act as members of a race, even while trying to
destroy racial categories.
Pluralism: Artists don't need to prove
anything to white society
An anthology of poetry, essays, plays, music and portraiture by both white and Black artists.
Individuality: This anthology
demonstrated "Negro art" as an expression of the individual Black
artist, as opposed to the dominant viewpoint at the time, which was that
"Negro art" was simply a cultural category
For Locke, prior Negro art was designed to play by the rules of the European art movements; it sought to demonstrate that the Negro was "civilized" and could meaningfully contribute to American (read: white) society. Naturaly, this forced older Negro art to be filled with stereotypes (positive or negative)
In the mind of America, says Locke, "the Negro has been more of a formula than a human being—a something to be argued about, condemned or defended…" This also points to work like Booker T. Washington's The Negro Problem
Ghettoization: Locke argues that in
being forced to refer to simply a cultural category; a "question" to be
investigated; Negro art is cut off from the rest of society. Worse Black
people do it to themselves: forcing art to serve propaganda, forcing
Black people to be a social category means to force the individual Black
person to be and view themself as a "social problem". They can't focus
on themselves as individuals; they exist secondarily to, and through the
lens of, social justice
Black Nationalism
Debated constantly with Langston Hughes
Satire that mocked the idea that there was any real difference between Black and white art.
Discovered and mentored Langston Hughes, Countee Cullen, and Jean Toomer
Inspired heavily by the Blues, boogie-woogie and stride
His word choice and structure was often simplistic, which led to a lot of criticism, from both Black and white audiences.
Respectability politics: Black middle
and upper class folk wanted to claim the place of their community
through beating white people at their own game: creating European
"sophisticated" art
The beginning of jazz poetry
Black artists should stop trying to copy white European forms, and instead need to find their unique voice
"We younger Negro artists who create now intend to express our individual dark-skinned selves without fear or shame. If white people are pleased we are glad. If they are not, it doesn’t matter. We know we are beautiful. And ugly too. The tom-tom cries and the tom-tom laughs. If colored people are pleased we are glad. If they are not, their displeasure doesn’t matter either. We build our temples for tomorrow, strong as we know how, and we stand on top of the mountain, free within ourselves."
Received a ton of criticism. The Pittsburgh Courier called him "the poet low-rate of Harlem". Other publications called Langston Hughes a "sewer dweller", his poetry "of the gutter"
Noble primitivism: Some white audiences
praised Hughes, but only in that they viewed his work as uncorrupted by
"higher" civilization
Dunbar was destroyed by white expectations; he was able to craft traditional European poetry better than a lot of white authors, but they didn't care — they just wanted to laugh at the dialect
Loved John Keats and Phillis Wheatley
He talked about Phillis Wheatley, FEWH, and Dunbar
AAE: Johnson felt that "dialect poetry"
was over; it could only exhibit humour or pathos